December 5th, 2008 / 3:34 pm
I Like __ A Lot

I like William Gaddis alot

I’m going to write about books and authors I like, but it won’t be ‘indie-lit,’ because I actually can’t keep up with everything, but I want to write about writing, so I am relying on books/authors I’ve read in the past. Hopefully, this will start a dialog and other contributors will also write posts in similar fashion. The goal is to get people reading what they might not have otherwise. I’m calling this series, “I like [blank] alot.” I encourage everyone to do this.

My first installment will be about William Gaddis. He’s not necessarily my ‘favorite’ writer, because taste is a malleable thing, but I think he’s ‘blown my mind’ the most in everything I’ve read in my life.

These posts will also provide context, like an intro or something. William Gaddis is most commonly grouped with Pynchon, but it’s a one-dimensional association. Gaddis himself said he didn’t like or understand Pynchon. Gaddis can be seen to have bridged Faulkner’s modernist tendencies (e.g. fragmented objectivity) and Pynchon’s post-modernism (he also chronologically fits the bill, writing exactly between the two). Gaddis is also sorta like the american Kafka; the former had an office job at a lawfirm his entire life. Somewhat cliché, but Gaddis hated the lit world back then, and only admitted to liking T.S. Eliot.

In JR, his second book (which in my mind did something no other book as done, which I’ll get into later), he incorporated the vernacular of american bureaucracy so accurately that 50% of the book is [sic]. He has been said to have made notes quoting his co-workers and adding it into his book.

I think JR won the National Book Award, but Gaddis is still ‘under-rated’ in the sense that only sorta crazy people read him. And the award was given ambivalently, like Gravity’s Rainbow, by a committee whom some of which didn’t actually read the book. Gaddis only wrote 4 books, and his last two were inconsequential knock-offs of his first two.

The Recognitions, his first book, also ‘blew my mind,’ and this is how: Gaddis exploited the reader’s tendency to forget things, or the nonchalant faith that the author’s best interest was to ‘take care’ of the reader. He was aware of how ‘fictional reality’ is rendered in the reader’s mind, and purposely fucked with it. Jonathan Franzen, and the contemporary social-realists, don’t like that shit (and I can understand why), but if you like to be fucked with, Gaddis is your man.

Here are some examples of his method:

In The Recognitions, the characters names slowly become interchangeable. Gaddis purposely introduces other characters with almost identical names (Esme, Elise, Elsy, Elly, Elyse, etc.) to confuse the reader. But there is a surreal component to this: the story is about pastiche and the death of ‘the original,’ (a big deal back then, think Warhol) and so the characters ‘caricaturize’ themselves as being copies of one another. Gaddis also does a lot of funny things, like halfway thru the book, the main character disappears and is never mentioned again. The subordinate characters go on and struggle for position as the main character. The book is about a painter who makes more money forging painting than painting his own, though that’s a really shallow description of the book. It’s really about the capacity of ‘character’ in a novel, and the artifice of its rendering. It’s also a haunting love story.

JR is 700 pages of uncited dialog (no “said John,” “replied Lisa,” etc.) The reader basically has to ‘dive in’ and, like some archeologist, retro-actively create a logical world using a paltry set of clues. The more the reader investigates, the more he/she discovers how intricate the novel was written, and how Gaddis leaves not only the right clues, but at the right time. So the ‘writing’ is not actually on the paper, it’s 80% in the reader’s mind. And, yes, he majorly fucks with you: there’s a scene where person A and person B are talking, and person A interrupts and says, “Oh, person C!” followed by descriptions which lead the reader to believe person C rang the door bell—and the reader bases the next 50pgs on that premise. 150 pages later, the reader realizes that person C came down the stairwell when person A says “Oh, person C,” and the person at the door was actually person D, which inverts the entire preceding narrative. Gaddis said he got the idea from T.S. Eliot’s play “The Cocktail Party,” in which a lot of the actor’s dialog takes place off-stage.

He also exploits the inherent fragmented perception that comes from reading fiction, how ‘truth’ (even fictional truth) is impossible. There’s a scene where a man looks in a rearview mirror from a taxi and sees a bouquet of flowers bouncing. It’s described in such a lyrical and memorable way, that it’s embedded in the reader’s memory like some archived signifier, some mental database which glue timelines together. Then some 200 pages later, another character in the book (in the context of the day the taxi ride took place) sees a penny on the ground and attempts numerous times to bend down and pick it up. And he’s holding a bouquet of flowers. These are just one of a myriad of moments when I was like, “holy fuck.”

This post is getting too long. I’ll finish quickly: If you want to be utterly mind fucked for a month straight, and carry the reading experience in your bone marrow forever, read The Recognitions or JR, just get a pen and pad of paper to take down notes. Flow charts and diagrams won’t hurt too.

Tags: , ,

94 Comments

  1. J

      also, I am jimmy chen

  2. J

      also, I am jimmy chen

  3. darby

      My guess is J is Jereme, perpetuating the schtik in the role of antagonist.

  4. darby

      My guess is J is Jereme, perpetuating the schtik in the role of antagonist.

  5. J

      no actually I’m Jonathan Safran Foer

  6. J

      gonna go take a crap and wipe my ass with money

  7. barry

      darby:

      great stuff on abjective. i especially like this saturday and last, keep it up man, good shit.

  8. J

      no actually I’m Jonathan Safran Foer

  9. J

      gonna go take a crap and wipe my ass with money

  10. barry

      darby:

      great stuff on abjective. i especially like this saturday and last, keep it up man, good shit.

  11. darby

      thanks barry. also at dogzplot, that ted powers piece was awesome.

  12. darby

      thanks barry. also at dogzplot, that ted powers piece was awesome.

  13. J
  14. J
  15. barry

      darby:

      thanks

      i am reconsidering my idea that J is jimmy. i know who it is.

  16. barry

      darby:

      thanks

      i am reconsidering my idea that J is jimmy. i know who it is.

  17. J

      No I’m not Itamar Moses

      really.

  18. J

      No I’m not Itamar Moses

      really.

  19. Brad D. Green

      Maybe I should change my name to B so I can by mysterious too. I wanna be mysterious like the cool kids.

  20. Brad D. Green

      Maybe I should change my name to B so I can by mysterious too. I wanna be mysterious like the cool kids.

  21. chris

      Jimmy,

      I really enjoyed this post and would love to read the other giants’ entries in this “I like _____ alot” series. Especially if the writers being spotlighted were historical rather than contemporary. This would be a neat way to discuss literary antecedents.

      I first came to Gaddis through AFOHO at a time when I really needed the kind of inspiration it offered (i.e. an entire text of unattributed dialogue). I never got around to reading TR, but you’ve peaked my interest.

      Anyways, just wanted to say thanks for your thoughtful post on an author that doesn’t seem to get talked about much.

  22. chris

      Jimmy,

      I really enjoyed this post and would love to read the other giants’ entries in this “I like _____ alot” series. Especially if the writers being spotlighted were historical rather than contemporary. This would be a neat way to discuss literary antecedents.

      I first came to Gaddis through AFOHO at a time when I really needed the kind of inspiration it offered (i.e. an entire text of unattributed dialogue). I never got around to reading TR, but you’ve peaked my interest.

      Anyways, just wanted to say thanks for your thoughtful post on an author that doesn’t seem to get talked about much.

  23. jereme

      J is not me. I do not really go into deep discussions about books. i would say ‘i liked it’ or ‘fuck that book’.

      i’m an idiot like that.

      i just woke up from partying. jimmy hurt my feelings. so i went out and saw a cloud, pissed on a street, almost got in several fist fights, pointed my middle finger at some police officers and i did some other shit i cannot recollect.

      i am currently reading ‘stranger in a strange place’. i will tell you if i like it or not.

      the writing is horrible though. like pushing needles through my gumline.

  24. jereme

      J is not me. I do not really go into deep discussions about books. i would say ‘i liked it’ or ‘fuck that book’.

      i’m an idiot like that.

      i just woke up from partying. jimmy hurt my feelings. so i went out and saw a cloud, pissed on a street, almost got in several fist fights, pointed my middle finger at some police officers and i did some other shit i cannot recollect.

      i am currently reading ‘stranger in a strange place’. i will tell you if i like it or not.

      the writing is horrible though. like pushing needles through my gumline.

  25. jereme

      ‘stranger in a strange land’ sorry. i am hung over and just woke up.

  26. jereme

      ‘stranger in a strange land’ sorry. i am hung over and just woke up.

  27. barry

      i think J is jason jordan…….

  28. barry

      i think J is jason jordan…….

  29. barry

      i’ve been playing this new sherlock holmes game on the pc so now i think im all sleuthy.

      i know i know. sherlock holmes pc games, what a fucking dork i am.

  30. barry

      i’ve been playing this new sherlock holmes game on the pc so now i think im all sleuthy.

      i know i know. sherlock holmes pc games, what a fucking dork i am.

  31. pr

      you’re fantastic, bg.

      i’ve never read gaddis and may never. hm. but i like this “writers i like” category. great idea.

      now i’m going to google jason jordon

  32. pr

      that guy had a great story in keystone.

  33. Brad Green

      Jason Jordon is freaking awesome. Even though he rejects me that doesn’t dent his awesomeness. He has that undentable type of awesomeness which makes me salivate and to which I aspire.

  34. Brad Green

      Jason Jordon is freaking awesome. Even though he rejects me that doesn’t dent his awesomeness. He has that undentable type of awesomeness which makes me salivate and to which I aspire.

  35. barry

      indeed. jason jordan is a great human being.

  36. barry

      indeed. jason jordan is a great human being.

  37. Brad D. Green

      I posted that at 5:03PM and was slightly drunk. Does that speak ill of me?

  38. Brad D. Green

      I posted that at 5:03PM and was slightly drunk. Does that speak ill of me?

  39. Frank Smythe

      Donchu forget the last coupla Gaddis books eiver. They’re pretty damn good.

  40. Frank Smythe

      Donchu forget the last coupla Gaddis books eiver. They’re pretty damn good.

  41. Anatomy of a Flash – Jimmy Chen (Guest post by Keith Nathan Brown) « BIG OTHER

      […] pieces you mention bring to mind William Gaddis’ intricate chaos, which I went into detail here. I’m still not over my reading of JR, which I will say is the most intense reading experience […]

  42. Beach Sloth gets William Gaddis’d | Newhandsweepstakes

      […] (thus being more influential, economically viable) though I love Jimmy Chen’s-William Gaddis-like writing, deconstructing ideas to the root suffering of man. That man’s sin is not Eve’s, and […]

  43. Gaddis and J R: Life With, By and Before | HTMLGIANT

      […] Further Reading The Gaddis Annotations “Stop Player. Joke No. 4″ by William Gaddis “Mr. Difficult” by Jonathan Franzen “Books People Wrote Because They Were Pissed About Writing” by Blake Butler “I like William Gaddis alot” by Jimmy Chen […]

  44. Gaddis and J R: Life With, By and Before | LITERARY GIANT

      […] Further Reading The Gaddis Annotations “Stop Player. Joke No. 4″ by William Gaddis “Mr. Difficult” by Jonathan Franzen “Books People Wrote Because They Were Pissed About Writing” by Blake Butler “I like William Gaddis alot” by Jimmy Chen […]