Reviews

On Listening to Franzen’s Freedom

“To me, the point of a novel is to take you to a still place. You can multitask with a lot of things, but you can’t really multitask reading a book. You’re either reading a book or you’re not.” – Jonathan Franzen, “Jonathan Franzen on Author Videos & the Novel”

In August of last year, a publicist at Macmillan sent a 19-disc audiobook of Freedom by Jonathan Franzen to the newspaper office where I work. She included a handwritten note on Macmillan stationary, “I hope you’ll consider revisiting the pleasures of audiobook with FREEDOM.”

“Audiobooks are great when surfing the internet. You can surf; play games, chat, Skype … There are lots of other ways you can multitask with Audiobooks.” – Jia Hunter, “Multitask Away With Audiobooks”

“The review will be, like, about folding laundry while listening to Freedom, or taking a shit while listening to Freedom, or being on Facebook while listening to Freedom,” I said to my editor. He nodded, mumbled, “Clever,” and made a note in his daily planner.

My wife rolled her eyes when I told her about the review. “Always with this clever shit,” she said.

“And how are you going to take notes when you’re wiping your ass? And how are you going to quote from an audiobook if you’re not taking any notes?”

myeditor:   yeah

no quotes is fine i guess

you’re going to slam him right?

me: that’s the idea

“New advances in technology have bought with it the evolution of the MP3 player as well as audiobooks. Never before has there been a time when it has been so easy to learn and absorb information and news while performing other various tasks.” – Jia Hunter, “Multitask Away With Audiobooks”

I started Freedom in the morning on the toilet, but I could only sit there for so long. I drove to the grocery store and listened to it near the vegetables. When Patti recalls being raped as a teenager, trying to tell her parents, trying to get them to listen to her, I was in the cereal aisle. I had my hand on a box of Grape Nuts for a long time – I don’t how long – before I dropped the box.

IMPORTANT CHARACTER NAMES IN FREEDOM FROM MEMORY

Walter, Eco-Friendly Patriarch

Patti, The Desperate Housewife

Their son, The Republican One

Their daughter, The Boring One

Richard Katz, Get it?

Walter’s Secretary, The Not White One

Texas Oilman, Boss Hogg

Conor Oberst, Yeah, that guy

“I was puzzled, and more than a little aggrieved, that nobody seemed able to discern this simple, clear idea in the text. How willfully stupid, I thought, these media people were!” – Jonathan Franzen, “A Word About This Book,” How to Be Alone

In the office, I told my editor that I wanted to get the plot wrong in my review, to misapply some crucial point, to be willfully stupid. “He likes to be right, I think, so I shouldn’t deny him,” I said.

The Grape Nuts thing kept happening. I stood in a doorway, my hand on the jamb, until someone tapped my shoulder. I sat in the driver’s seat of my car, forgot to start it.

Freedom was still playing while I laid on the couch that night, watching the local news on mute. The newscaster was narrating the novel, telling me about Richard Katz between clips of police cars flashing red and blue, a shopping mall bathed in florescent light.

My wife went to bed while I was still on the couch, closed the door.

We’re not actually married. We told her parents that we had eloped and they sent us kitchen appliances, some money, a couch. That was a couple years ago. We thought that this trick meant we weren’t buying into a domestic facade, that we were smarter than that.

Another way of saying that would be: “We didn’t want to be characters in a Jonathan Franzen novel.”

“Identification is usually supposed to be largely unconscious: a reader may be aware that she likes a given character, but not that she actually see that character as an alter ego, a version of her, or a projection of her aspirations for herself.” – Wikipedia, “Identification (Literature)”

She walked back into the living room when light was beginning to seep through the windows. “You’ve been up all night?”

I made a pot of coffee and she said, “What’s it about?” I told her that it was about a woman whose husband won’t fuck her the way she needs to be fucked, that he’s too vanilla-liberal and she doesn’t know how to say what she needs and that there are other plots, too, and they’re mostly about people not being able to say or know what they want or need.

“We could listen to the rest of it together,” I said. She rolled her eyes, the standard response, and sat down on the couch anyway. “Fuck it,” she said. “Sure.”

I wanted to ask her if she thought of me more as Walter or more as Richard. I wanted to ask her what it was like when she thought about my old best friend, the one she used to fuck. I wanted to ask her about the comparisons she would make in an autobiography, to tell me now so that we would stop pretending to not think about them.

“Audiobooks are great for learning while doing mundane house chores or other forms of chores like guttering, painting, cleaning out the shed, moving furniture or the dreaded mowing … listening to audiobooks allows you to focus on the positive audiobook not the negative mundane chore you are doing.” – Jia Hunter, “Multitask Away With Audiobooks”

After a few hours on the couch, she said, “What about your gimmick? Don’t you need to be taking a shit or weeding the garden or something?”

“I can just make that up, right? Like I can just say I heard this while I was doing that and it’ll work just the same.”

“Cheater.”

I missed all the parts that we talked over.

“Audiobooks can now be enjoyed while exercising. It doesn’t matter whether it’s jogging in the park, riding your bike to work, pounding up and down on equipment in a gym or walking along a beach.” – Jia Hunter, “Multitask Away With Audiobooks”

I start trying to kiss her during a scene about Walter. “I should write about fucking while listening to Franzen,” I said. She brushed my hands away and said, “I thought you were going to make it up.”

The first time we had sex, she slapped me across the face, open palm. We fell in love quick. We used to take little key bumps in bed. She started keeping a knife on her bedside table in those months. “Just so we know it’s there,” she said.

We got fake-married and quit doing drugs. Quit having sex, too.

“Audiobooks are great for learning and studying at the same time. Audiobooks give you the ability to listen to study material and the freedom to take notes at the same time … Slow reader’s have a huge advantage as well as they are able to take more in while listening.” – Jia Hunter, “Multitask Away With Audiobooks”

“If you’re going to make it up, make up something more interesting. Tell them that I tied you up and put a ball gag in your mouth and that the safe word was ‘Freedom.’”

When you say ‘Freedom’ with a ball-gag in your mouth, it sounds like EEE-OMM, EEE-OMM.

“So, the ropes would be, like, a metaphor for marriage or domestic life or something?”

The republican son swallows his wedding ring and then searches through his shit for it. This is described in detail, his hands breaking the fecal matter carefully, anxiously. When she looked at me during this scene, I wondered if she was also reminded of our relationship.

“It’s just like what Franzen keeps hitting us over the head with, that our freedom is our bondage or whatever. So, bondage is the right metaphor right?”

“You’re saying that I should hit you in the head, too?”

“Relaxing and keeping hygienic at the same time … just lay back in a nice bubble filled bath, press play on the iPod … and the pressure is off the study and onto relaxing and cleaning.” – Jia Hunter, “Multitask Away With Audiobooks”

“The problem with Freedom” returns about 103,000 results on Google.

me:  there’s a problem

the Franzen book is good

myeditor:  really?

me:  yeah

i can still write that story though

it’ll just be, like, about how he’s right

or something

I wanted to tell her that maybe she was like Patti or maybe she was like Richard or maybe she was like Walter. I thought that if we could just figure out who were identifying with, that if we could just hold our breath and search through our shit for long enough, that something would turn up, that we could make it right.

I was wrong.

“You can also learn while sleeping with audiobooks … plug in the headphones and have a nice peaceful sleep while listening to your favourite audiobook.” – Jia Hunter, “Multitask Away With Audiobooks”

The editor calls me from his desk, “I don’t think we’re going to have room for the, uh, Franzen thing.”

I think I left the discs at her house when I moved out. I don’t know how Freedom ends.

* * *

Wyatt Williams is a contributing writer at Creative Loafing and editor of Joyland South.

Tags: ,

32 Comments

  1. Scott mcclanahan

      Great post, Wyatt.

  2. Frank Goodish

      This is great shit, Wyatt, I searched through the whole thing and found a lot to love. “I missed all the parts that we talked over.” That was my favorite. Also, I read “Jim Hunter” at first, not “Jia Hunter.” I figured ol ‘Catfish was listening to an audiotape when he shot his foot off, but then I realized he was too old for such a thing.

  3. Amy McDaniel

      Wow. When I saw the title on my twitter feed I didn’t click because I thought I knew what it would say, but when I came to the sure and saw you wrote it, I read it, and it is most definitely not what I expected. Really really nice writing. Thanks Wyatt! Write here more!?

  4. Laur

      This is absolutely gorgeous. I had to search for Jia Hunter, content producer. He’s real. Maybe all of it is, in which case – – – I hope you find out how Freedom ends.

  5. Frank Goodish

      Now I get a bit better why N Pollack used to “wipe his ass” on stage with pages from “The Corrections.” I think Mr. Franzen and his glasses deserve a lot more critiquing like this from Wyatt and anyone even close to his level of “bringin’ da funny.”

  6. drew kalbach

      best review of freedom so far

  7. M. Kitchell

      this is the first review of Freedom I have read

  8. KKB

      This is awesome!

  9. NLY

      Nice.

  10. Cameron Pierce

      This is a sweet-ass review.

  11. deadgod

      I think one couldn’t make a sound like “MM” with something holding her or his lips apart, as with a device fastened in the mouth from outside the mouth.

  12. Otus

      Stick your fist in your fist in your mouth, hold it mostly with you teeth, position it so that your top and bottom lips touch your hand but not the sides of your mouth, and try again. It’s close. You just need room for air to escape.

  13. deadgod

      Conceding your illumination that it’s possible to make the “m” sound while being orally (auto-)fisted(/ing), I think that, if one’s lips are held apart so as not to be able to form upper and lower seals with whatever is intruding into the mouth and holding those lips apart or a seal with each other, as with a “ball gag”, one couldn’t make a sound like “MM”.

      Though, picturing again the fiction (?) that the reviewer’s (fictive?) former main slam suggests and the reviewer imagines (??), I guess that unusually long, flexible lips of the gagged safe-word vocalizer could be stretched around a “rope” harness holding the ball in place so as to touch either each other or to form seals with the (extrusive) ball and/or harness, thereby enabling the restrainee to make the “MM” sound accurately.

  14. Anonymous

      vipstores.net

  15. shaun gannon

      god damn this fucking owned

  16. Sean

      glow

  17. James Yeh

      This is absolutely great. Knocked it out of the park. Love how the quotes are used, love how the personal stuff blends with the book stuff. All around awesome.

  18. Anonymous

      best thing on Freedom ever. Only one I read the whole way through.

  19. Frank Goodish

      Good God, you could destroy the allure of any fetish with your analysis.

  20. DD

      its okay, frank. he does the same when he talks about books too.

  21. Marcus Speh

      i still can’t get with franzen but i loved this innovative review. «When you say ‘Freedom’ with a ball-gag in your mouth, it sounds like EEE-OMM, EEE-OMM.» will stay with me for a while. perhaps i’ll get the audiobook just to get to the inside of your experience. i got the free sample chapter for my kindle but it made me yawn quickly. on the other hand maybe franzen is for audio only? a little like joyce whom i much prefer to hear read aloud. aww, i digress. this was gud.

  22. Marcus Speh

      i still can’t get with franzen but i loved this innovative review. «When you say ‘Freedom’ with a ball-gag in your mouth, it sounds like EEE-OMM, EEE-OMM.» will stay with me for a while. perhaps i’ll get the audiobook just to get to the inside of your experience. i got the free sample chapter for my kindle but it made me yawn quickly. on the other hand maybe franzen is for audio only? a little like joyce whom i much prefer to hear read aloud. aww, i digress. this was gud.

  23. Matthew Salesses

      hm, now i almost want to read it.

  24. zusya

      “I started Freedom in the morning on the toilet, but I could only sit there for so long. I drove to the grocery store and listened to it near the vegetables. When Patti recalls being raped as a teenager, trying to tell her parents, trying to get them to listen to her, I was in the cereal aisle. I had my hand on a box of Grape Nuts for a long time – I don’t how long – before I dropped the box.”

      gold.

  25. deadgod

      Fetishize vulnerability, and the “allure” of your fetish will be impervious.

      Make “Continue” your safe word.

  26. mimi

      Yes

      Continue

  27. Aaron G

      man, this is good. killed it.

      “I missed all the parts that we talked over.”

  28. Uygyu

      vipstores.net

  29. NA

      wow. incredible.

  30. Beverly Akerman

      i especially liked the part where walter & patti “re-enact” the rape scene and this somehow heals her. great feminist stuff! (that’s sarcasm, by the way!)

      it was bloated and kind of pointless…i did get choked up at the end (quite unusual for me, with a book, anyway) but i read the puff piece in Time magazine–he’d have been better off having that baby, after all.

      imho.

  31. Casey

      This is the shit, I wholeheartedly agree (and enjoying the pun there).

  32. Eric Celeste

      I am in agreeance.