October 26th, 2009 / 8:08 pm
Author Spotlight & Massive People & Mean

Cowering Literary Peons

This post’s a bit apples and oranges. Or rotten bananas and rotten (or as we say “Vrot”) pineapples. In fact it’s not very organized. And it is a response, in a way, to Blake Butler’s 15 Towering Literary Giants.

But, what’s a Cowering Literary Peon??

—a weasel?

—an overrated supposed Giant?

—a talentless p.o.s.?

—a fucking weasel?

—a fraction and no more than a real Towering Giant who came before?

A mix maybe. Or maybe just one of the above. And again, this is all apples and bananas. Etc. Etc.

1) Tony Hoagland. Definitely a Cowering Literary Peon! Over-rated and a jackass, it’s amazing this clown carries any sort of clout. But he does. Within the poetry world. And he’s a teacher. And of course piss runs down hill. And so his ass gets licked by plenty of young beautiful people. The only good thing’s that outside of the poetry world he’s just a normal little weasel.

2) Cormac McCarthy. Let the howling begin! But I’m not the first to go after McCarthy and it’s because it’s obvious (how can u dispute the logic of “it’s obvious”). He’s way over-rated. My first McCarthy torture I endured was The Road but I gave the Redness in the West a chance because people I respected told me The Road was the wrong entry point. Well, well, well. McCarthy has his strengths of course but his archaisms, compounds, and tired and overreaching bring-out-the-horns-and-drums “profound” moments make for (like these last phrases) a strange mosquito-annoying read.

3) Tim O’Brien– I’ve not read anything besides The Things They Carried and that’s because that book was such an unreal beating I wouldn’t dare touch another of his. Twice shy and all that. All smoke and mirrors. I’m lying. I’m not lying. O, I am lying. O, no, I’m not. O, but I am. Just a little. Not at all. Completely. Barf!!! Story-truth is truer than conventional-truth. Double Barf!

4) Maya Angelou. The Caged Peon Singeth.

5) Russel Edson. Some wonderful poems but after you read Henri Michaux you realize Edson’s best poems come straight out of some of Michaux’s most ordinary and gimmicky work. A fraction of Michaux, literally. He’s like Michaux’s left buttocks. Not bad. But…..

6) God. I mean the bible’s good and the ten commandments, etc, etc, (such style and seething prose) but is this guy really deserving of the most read novel in all of time? Yes, this guy’s a Cowering Literary Peon. And all his cowering little weasel scribes.

7) Seth Abramson. I’m not going to say anything good or bad about Seth (that’s just not my style) but there are so many hate-filled fanatics out there who’d probably take out a contract on me if I didn’t include him here as a Cowering Literary Peon. So, sorry Seth, I’m bowing to popular (or unpopular) demand.

And, so here we are, and I’ve only listed 7 here because I’m feeling God-like. Other candidates are perennial whipping boys like Billy Collins and Jonathan Saffron Flowers.

Junot Diaz deserves a good mention and a good, thorough beating. Like the crusades. In waves, over centuries. Orders of knights dedicated to kicking his worthless and righteous ass.

Tags: , , , , ,

74 Comments

  1. Ken Baumann

      Fight on!

      I read this while listening to Dopesmoker by Sleep. Highly recommended.

  2. Ken Baumann

      Fight on!

      I read this while listening to Dopesmoker by Sleep. Highly recommended.

  3. Daniel Nester

      What is Seth looking down at?

  4. Daniel Nester

      What is Seth looking down at?

  5. Daniel Nester

      Come to think of it: Where are all these people looking off to? It’s like they’re all Richard Dreyfuss in Their Own Private Speilberg Movie.

  6. Daniel Nester

      Come to think of it: Where are all these people looking off to? It’s like they’re all Richard Dreyfuss in Their Own Private Speilberg Movie.

  7. Gene Morgan

      Hoagland gave me a B+ in my undergraduate poetry class the semester I had my first child. 

      I didn’t miss a single class. I think I missed one assignment.

      He verbally assaulted me once for writing a poem about feces for an in-class excercise.

      I have other grievances, but it’s not worth the time typing them out. A first class piece of shit.

  8. Gene Morgan

      Hoagland gave me a B+ in my undergraduate poetry class the semester I had my first child. 

      I didn’t miss a single class. I think I missed one assignment.

      He verbally assaulted me once for writing a poem about feces for an in-class excercise.

      I have other grievances, but it’s not worth the time typing them out. A first class piece of shit.

  9. Gene Morgan

      And no, I’m not a whiny bitch for complaining about a B+.

  10. Gene Morgan

      And no, I’m not a whiny bitch for complaining about a B+.

  11. Trey

      I fucking hate Tony Hoagland.

  12. Trey

      I fucking hate Tony Hoagland.

  13. Beniamino

      Thanks for not even giving Junot a picture and a full mention

  14. Beniamino

      Thanks for not even giving Junot a picture and a full mention

  15. tom k

      Martin amis should be in here

      Quote: On the subject of curbing terrorism, he said: ‘There is a definite urge – don’t you have it? – to say, “The Muslim community will have to suffer until it gets its house in order”.
      ‘Not letting them travel. Deportation – further down the road. Curtailing of freedoms. Strip-searching people who look like they’re from the Middle East or from Pakistan. Discriminatory stuff, until it hurts the whole community and they start getting tough with their children

      What the fuck is wrong with martin amis?

  16. tom k

      Martin amis should be in here

      Quote: On the subject of curbing terrorism, he said: ‘There is a definite urge – don’t you have it? – to say, “The Muslim community will have to suffer until it gets its house in order”.
      ‘Not letting them travel. Deportation – further down the road. Curtailing of freedoms. Strip-searching people who look like they’re from the Middle East or from Pakistan. Discriminatory stuff, until it hurts the whole community and they start getting tough with their children

      What the fuck is wrong with martin amis?

  17. stu

      You like Tao Lin.

  18. stu

      You like Tao Lin.

  19. Tim Jones-Yelvington

      Can I add JCO?

  20. Tim Jones-Yelvington

      Can I add JCO?

  21. Catherine Lacey

      Cowering masses of MFA students.

  22. Catherine Lacey

      Cowering masses of MFA students.

  23. Catherine Lacey

      I am coming out of manuscript leave just to say this post is badass. See you guys in December.

  24. Catherine Lacey

      I am coming out of manuscript leave just to say this post is badass. See you guys in December.

  25. Ryan Call

      cowering literary penguins

  26. Ryan Call

      cowering literary penguins

  27. Sean

      your post sucks, Rauan. How about getting wings on your plane before you launch the motherfucker? There are people aboard (though not many).

      S

  28. Sean

      your post sucks, Rauan. How about getting wings on your plane before you launch the motherfucker? There are people aboard (though not many).

      S

  29. Sean

      I can not believe anyone still reads Tao Lin. You people are so 19 century.

  30. Sean

      I can not believe anyone still reads Tao Lin. You people are so 19 century.

  31. Sean

      Did you forget that John Lennon 100% sucks, you suck-ass?

      The funny thing about you saying Tony Hoagland sucks is you actually thought ONE READER here though Hoagland did not suck. Wow.

      Conclusion: YOU SUCK WORSE THAN HOAGLAND!!!

      (I hate to say that, but it is Mean Week. I also hate to put this aside in here, so lame, but I am too nice for Mean Week! Damn.)

  32. Sean

      Did you forget that John Lennon 100% sucks, you suck-ass?

      The funny thing about you saying Tony Hoagland sucks is you actually thought ONE READER here though Hoagland did not suck. Wow.

      Conclusion: YOU SUCK WORSE THAN HOAGLAND!!!

      (I hate to say that, but it is Mean Week. I also hate to put this aside in here, so lame, but I am too nice for Mean Week! Damn.)

  33. Blake Butler

      i heart ron, except for where he fucked up on cormac. but i respect the dis. booyah

  34. Blake Butler

      i heart ron, except for where he fucked up on cormac. but i respect the dis. booyah

  35. Ross Brighton

      Fuck him. And David Wohjan (or however you spell his “I’m white but have ethnic intrigue” last name

  36. Ross Brighton

      Fuck him. And David Wohjan (or however you spell his “I’m white but have ethnic intrigue” last name

  37. Ross Brighton

      John Lennon gets a bit of reflected glory from bangin’ Yoko Ono.
      Hear about that wicked piece of conceptual art she did? She broke up a band that was bigger than jesus. She should start a chuch.

  38. Ross Brighton

      John Lennon gets a bit of reflected glory from bangin’ Yoko Ono.
      Hear about that wicked piece of conceptual art she did? She broke up a band that was bigger than jesus. She should start a chuch.

  39. Aaron

      hey, i thought this was mean week. can we heart people? at least tell him he sucks too

  40. Aaron

      hey, i thought this was mean week. can we heart people? at least tell him he sucks too

  41. Clapper

      This list is seriously lacking in Sherman Alexie.

  42. Clapper

      This list is seriously lacking in Sherman Alexie.

  43. Ross Brighton

      That’s racist.

  44. Ross Brighton

      That’s racist.

  45. reynard

      is this an excerpt from stuff white people like?

  46. reynard

      is this an excerpt from stuff white people like?

  47. alan

      fucking stoner

  48. alan

      fucking stoner

  49. Rauan Klassnik

      thanks, Sean,…. but you’re flying so high i can barely hear you down here,…..

  50. Rauan Klassnik

      sure thing…. all he deserves is a massive beating……

  51. Rauan Klassnik

      thanks, Sean,…. but you’re flying so high i can barely hear you down here,…..

  52. Rauan Klassnik

      sure thing…. all he deserves is a massive beating……

  53. Rauan Klassnik

      from my experience Wojahn is actually a very nice guy…. but,….

  54. Rauan Klassnik

      they’re all just being “deep”,… naturally deep…. deep-in-the-moment deep,…..

  55. Rauan Klassnik

      from my experience Wojahn is actually a very nice guy…. but,….

  56. Rauan Klassnik

      they’re all just being “deep”,… naturally deep…. deep-in-the-moment deep,…..

  57. Rauan Klassnik

      you are too nice… bring it, man…. really bring it,…..

  58. Rauan Klassnik

      you are too nice… bring it, man…. really bring it,…..

  59. Michael James

      why am I seeing a lot more “u” for “you” and 2 for to/too on HTML Giant lately. All these chatroom/IM stuff is bothering me in articles about literature. That may seem like a stuffy statement, but considering HTMLG has always been some intelligent shit, these terms reserved for chatrooms and IMs are leaking into would-be dope articles like teenagers putting them on job applications.

      WTF HTMLG!? (i mean, WTF HTMLG[INTERROBANG])

  60. Michael James

      why am I seeing a lot more “u” for “you” and 2 for to/too on HTML Giant lately. All these chatroom/IM stuff is bothering me in articles about literature. That may seem like a stuffy statement, but considering HTMLG has always been some intelligent shit, these terms reserved for chatrooms and IMs are leaking into would-be dope articles like teenagers putting them on job applications.

      WTF HTMLG!? (i mean, WTF HTMLG[INTERROBANG])

  61. barry

      no DAVE EGGERS on this list? really?

  62. barry

      no DAVE EGGERS on this list? really?

  63. EC

      Next to the dictionary entry for Cowering Literary Peon is picture of James Wood.

  64. EC

      Next to the dictionary entry for Cowering Literary Peon is picture of James Wood.

  65. Charles Dodd White

      Seconds on Sherman Alexie

  66. Charles Dodd White

      Seconds on Sherman Alexie

  67. mathias

      Wojahn is a German surname.

  68. mathias

      Wojahn is a German surname.

  69. james yeh

      what’s wrong with sherman alexie? i have my own gripes, sure, but i’d be interested to hear. despite certain, let’s say, “thematic recurrences” in his work over the years, his first book of stories kind of kicks some serious ass.

      or are you just talking about the personality slash entity that is sherman alexie?

  70. james yeh

      what’s wrong with sherman alexie? i have my own gripes, sure, but i’d be interested to hear. despite certain, let’s say, “thematic recurrences” in his work over the years, his first book of stories kind of kicks some serious ass.

      or are you just talking about the personality slash entity that is sherman alexie?

  71. Charles Dodd White

      James,

      I guess it’s mostly his personality, though I’ve found his stories to be mechanical and his characters uniformly two dimensional. I haven’t read INDIAN KILLER, though, and several folks have said I might enjoy that one.

  72. Charles Dodd White

      James,

      I guess it’s mostly his personality, though I’ve found his stories to be mechanical and his characters uniformly two dimensional. I haven’t read INDIAN KILLER, though, and several folks have said I might enjoy that one.

  73. Gregfellows

      wow. jealousy sure is ugly. i can understand disliking works, disagreeing with how an author writes, and on and on…but at least comment on their work with some sense of thoughtfulness and engage with it in a critical way. Yes, go grapple with literary giants, by all means, yes! But when you find conflict, have a little respect, and write something worth reading.

  74. Surfric

      If you miss one assigniment in a course, you shouldn’t even get a B at all