June 7th, 2010 / 9:04 pm
Snippets

Deborah Treisman responds to Qs about the New Yorker 20 Under 40 list via live chat. Heheh: “DEBORAH TREISMAN: I have a degree in Comparative Literature from UC Berkeley. I don’t think there’s only one kind of university at which aspiring writers can get an education. There’s an enormous range of educational opportunity out there.”

38 Comments

  1. Dreezer

      Good grief.

  2. Dreezer

      Good grief.

  3. Tim Jones-Yelvington

      Some of these questions. Wow.

  4. Tim Jones-Yelvington

      Some of these questions. Wow.

  5. Brendan Connell

      If they were trying not to annoint undiscovered writers, than what gives with Téa Obreht?

  6. Brendan Connell

      If they were trying not to annoint undiscovered writers, than what gives with Téa Obreht?

  7. Brendan Connell

      I think the most giving line in this thing is “four of the writers on the list had not been published in the magazine before.”

      So, basically, this is a list of people under 40 who have been published in the New Yorker. Now it makes sense.

  8. Brendan Connell

      I think the most giving line in this thing is “four of the writers on the list had not been published in the magazine before.”

      So, basically, this is a list of people under 40 who have been published in the New Yorker. Now it makes sense.

  9. Brooks Sterritt

      “I’m afraid that Aimee Bender is 40, which made her ineligible.” Ouch.

  10. Brooks Sterritt

      “I’m afraid that Aimee Bender is 40, which made her ineligible.” Ouch.

  11. zusya17

      all that needs to be said about this list: “This is an egregiously truncated list, self-restricted to North America.” (from Joshua Ferris’ Q&A)

  12. d

      Her novel excerpt/short story in the New Yorker was pretty awesome, and I imagine they think the manuscript of her upcoming novel is pretty awesome as well.

  13. d

      Her novel excerpt/short story in the New Yorker was pretty awesome, and I imagine they think the manuscript of her upcoming novel is pretty awesome as well.

  14. Brendan Connell

      Which says a lot, since many of the best writers (in any age group) clearly aren’t writing in English.

  15. Brendan Connell

      Which says a lot, since many of the best writers (in any age group) clearly aren’t writing in English.

  16. Dreezer

      Good grief.

  17. Tim Jones-Yelvington

      Some of these questions. Wow.

  18. Brendan Connell

      If they were trying not to annoint undiscovered writers, than what gives with Téa Obreht?

  19. Brendan Connell

      I think the most giving line in this thing is “four of the writers on the list had not been published in the magazine before.”

      So, basically, this is a list of people under 40 who have been published in the New Yorker. Now it makes sense.

  20. Brooks Sterritt

      “I’m afraid that Aimee Bender is 40, which made her ineligible.” Ouch.

  21. zusya17

      that’s it. i’m naming my baby “Coffeé” instead.

  22. d

      Her novel excerpt/short story in the New Yorker was pretty awesome, and I imagine they think the manuscript of her upcoming novel is pretty awesome as well.

  23. Brendan Connell

      Which says a lot, since many of the best writers (in any age group) clearly aren’t writing in English.

  24. rk

      I’m glad they all had talent in common. I thought it was something else.

  25. rk

      I’m glad they all had talent in common. I thought it was something else.

  26. Amber

      I enjoyed this answer (in response to the question, “are you an aspiring writer?”) :

      “No, I’m not. I think it would be very difficult to assess and edit fiction all day and then go home and try to write it.”

      Yes. Just imagine.

  27. Amber

      I enjoyed this answer (in response to the question, “are you an aspiring writer?”) :

      “No, I’m not. I think it would be very difficult to assess and edit fiction all day and then go home and try to write it.”

      Yes. Just imagine.

  28. rk

      I’m glad they all had talent in common. I thought it was something else.

  29. King Wenclas

      The stories from the Twenty presented so far are oppressively mediocre. Except for Foer’s, which is idiocy.

  30. King Wenclas

      The stories from the Twenty presented so far are oppressively mediocre. Except for Foer’s, which is idiocy.

  31. Amber

      I enjoyed this answer (in response to the question, “are you an aspiring writer?”) :

      “No, I’m not. I think it would be very difficult to assess and edit fiction all day and then go home and try to write it.”

      Yes. Just imagine.

  32. derick

      oh god, they are all so boring.

  33. derick

      oh god, they are all so boring.

  34. derick

      oh god, they are all so boring.

  35. King Wenclas

      The stories from the Twenty presented so far are oppressively mediocre. Except for Foer’s, which is idiocy.

  36. Comment2000

      The NY Post speaks:

      The New Yorker’s “Summer Fiction” issue focuses on authors under 40 and the resulting material seems, well, youthful. Jonathan Safran Foer, 33, chronicles the trials of an aged couple with all the wisdom and sensitivity of a stand-up comedian: “I was always watching movie trailers on my computer. You were always wiping surfaces.” In a story about a glamorous Hollywood party, Joshua Ferris, 35, scribbles endlessly about whether the protagonist wasn’t invited because of an e-mail glitch. F. Scott Fitzgerald it ain’t. The better pieces tend to grapple with various hardships, as if to counter an alarming trend of triteness.

      http://www.nypost.com/p/news/business/paradise_pages_53hHzqtjK71jAL23yYtM8O/1#ixzz0qOLhGK65

  37. Comment2000

      The NY Post speaks:

      The New Yorker’s “Summer Fiction” issue focuses on authors under 40 and the resulting material seems, well, youthful. Jonathan Safran Foer, 33, chronicles the trials of an aged couple with all the wisdom and sensitivity of a stand-up comedian: “I was always watching movie trailers on my computer. You were always wiping surfaces.” In a story about a glamorous Hollywood party, Joshua Ferris, 35, scribbles endlessly about whether the protagonist wasn’t invited because of an e-mail glitch. F. Scott Fitzgerald it ain’t. The better pieces tend to grapple with various hardships, as if to counter an alarming trend of triteness.

      http://www.nypost.com/p/news/business/paradise_pages_53hHzqtjK71jAL23yYtM8O/1#ixzz0qOLhGK65

  38. Comment2000

      The NY Post speaks:

      The New Yorker’s “Summer Fiction” issue focuses on authors under 40 and the resulting material seems, well, youthful. Jonathan Safran Foer, 33, chronicles the trials of an aged couple with all the wisdom and sensitivity of a stand-up comedian: “I was always watching movie trailers on my computer. You were always wiping surfaces.” In a story about a glamorous Hollywood party, Joshua Ferris, 35, scribbles endlessly about whether the protagonist wasn’t invited because of an e-mail glitch. F. Scott Fitzgerald it ain’t. The better pieces tend to grapple with various hardships, as if to counter an alarming trend of triteness.

      http://www.nypost.com/p/news/business/paradise_pages_53hHzqtjK71jAL23yYtM8O/1#ixzz0qOLhGK65